Thanks for the fast reply guys. He showed me a few rounds he didn't clean because he thought were too bad (they were). The cleaned ones look good though, a little dull, but no pits. He confirmed that they were in for less than a minute.Agreed it would depend on how bad of shape it was for me. I also would dry tumble. When he cleaned it if it stayed submerged or in a very wet environment too long I would be afraid of squib loads and duds if the powder/primer got wet.